The Case for Institutional Pacifism

Image: Virginia Guard Public Affairs [CC/Flickr]

Event details

Department of International Relations Seminar

Date & time

Friday 20 April 2018


PSC Reading Room 4.27, Hedley Bull Centre (130), Garran Road, ANU
ANU Canberra


Dr Ned Dobos, UNSW Canberra


Bell School

Pacifism, in its most familiar form, is the view that waging war is never morally justified—call this the pacifism-of-acts. This is to be carefully distinguished from what we might call the pacifism-of-institutions. The latter position is not characterised by an absolute objection to waging war with the military resources that we have amassed. It is characterised, rather, by an objection to the amassing of those resources to begin with. To put it another war, while the pacifism-of-acts condemns military operations, institutional pacifists object to the very existence of the military establishment. It might be assumed that the pacifism-of-acts and that pacifism-of-institutions stand or fall together. If all modern war is unjust then obviously we ought to eliminate the possibility and temptation of ever engaging in it. Hence pacifism-of-acts makes demilitarization a moral imperative. On the other hand, if it is sometimes permissible to wage war then presumably it must be permissible to prepare for it by building war-making capacity. So, on the face of it, if there is a compelling argument for the pacifism-of-acts then there is a compelling argument for the pacifism-of-institutions, and vice versa. This view is mistaken I think. The seminar presents arguments for the pacifism of institutions which do not rely on or presuppose a commitment to the pacifism of acts.

Dr Ned Doboss is Senior Lecturer in International and Political Studies at UNSW Canberra. He is the author of Insurrection and Intervention (Cambridge University Press, 2012), and The New Pacifism (Oxford University Press, forthcoming). Ned was a Visiting Scholar with the Oxford Uehiro Centre for Practical Ethics, and is a Senior Global Justice Fellow at the MacMillan Centre for International Studies at Yale. He is currently Assistant Regional Director of the International Society for Military Ethics, Asia-Pacific Division.

Updated:  23 March 2016/Responsible Officer:  Su-Ann Tan/Page Contact:  CAP Web Team